Menopause and perimenopause and andropause - oh my!
Mid-life hormone health is such a hot topic these days..and for good reason! For the first time in decades, we're hearing widespread discussion and validation of these important hormone changes and the need for treatment. Doctors are learning, black box warnings are disappearing, and social media is exploding. This is all great news.
Yet, in this current information age, mainstream awareness also means a lot of confusion. It can be terribly overwhelming to try to wade through all the conflicting advice and opinions you're hearing and reading.
That’s why we’ve decided to write an article tackling all the biggest questions about midlife hormonal transitions – perimenopause misconceptions, the impact of cortisol, joint pain in peri/menopause and testosterone replacement for men.
Check it all out or just scroll to what’s relevant to YOU.
The 3 (New) Perimenopause Misconceptions
Notice that I said NEW misconceptions...That’s because the OLD perimenopause misconception is that there is no perimenopause! Glad to have at least mostly moved beyond that these days!
Yet with public awareness comes confusion (and associated anxiety!) so let’s start off by clearing up the 3 biggest myths I see echoed on social media…
1. “You need to get your labs checked.”
In perimenopause, estrogen levels fluctuate wildly with an overall downward trend. Finding out your estrogen level at one random moment unfortunately does not offer any useful information about where you are in perimenopause or how to address it. Progesterone shows a more steady decline over time but has even bigger variation within the menstrual cycle. For these reasons, perimenopause is fully a clinical diagnosis, meaning it is based on your symptoms and history. If someone still has a regular cycle and is complaining mostly of PMS symptoms, then an argument could be made for checking labs a week before their period, but even then, these numbers need to be taken with a grain of salt. There can, however, be a reason to check testosterone in perimenopause, since those numbers are less fluctuating and testosterone supplementation can sometimes be helpful. But if someone is telling you that you need to buy a package from them to get all your hormones labs checked, you don’t.
2. “You need to be on hormones.”
Earlier this year the FDA removed from estrogen patches the black box warnings for cardiovascular disease, breast cancer, and dementia, deeming those risks to be outdated and misapplied. This decision, combined with increased education and online access, has led to an explosion of estrogen prescriptions, to the point that we now have a massive shortage of these medications. If you are in your 40s then it is very likely that you’ve got multiple friends and family members on “the patch” and questioning why you are not. Everyone’s doing it. You should be too, right? Well, maaaaybe. Some perimenopausal women do really great on hormones. Some do not. And some don’t do well on hormones and then we try a year later and then they do great on hormones. The issue is that in perimenopause you still have a good amount of your own hormones, so when you add more to the system, you can get side effects like bloating, pain, irregular bleeding or irritability. And because perimenopause is an inherently tumultuous time hormonally, the treatment response can be inconsistent with some things getting better but some things getting worse, or feeling good part of the month but not at other times. Once you are in menopause (no period for a year) then it’s quite easy to know what to do with hormones but before that it is a lot of trial and error and sometimes the best thing to do is to focus on your overall health using lots of non-hormone tools, and put HRT aside to revisit again in the future.
3. “You must prepare! (And be afraid!)”
I am extremely happy that women are talking about perimenopause, educating themselves and advocating for their health. But a lot of the content online will have you believe that you have got a lot of work to do and you are already behind. The messaging is that if you have not tested these labs, purchased these supplements, changed your diet, started lifting weights, gotten on hormones, etc., then you are not prepared for the havoc perimenopause is about to wreak in your life. Be afraid! Be very afraid! There is no denying that perimenopause is a huge transition that can impact many aspects of a woman’s life, not only physically but emotionally and spiritually. But there absolutely are some women that feel completely fine at this stage of life. There are some women who roll all the way through menopause unscathed. Yes, most women notice changes and need support, but it is not always terrible and we usually can deal with issues as they come up. So if you are feeling good right now, you do not have to do anything to get ready and you don't have to worry. If you do want to do something, then the best preparation is to focus on the foundations of your health - sleep, food, movement, water. During times of transition, always good to go back to the basics!
The Cortisol, Testosterone, Estrogen Connections
Cortisol gets a really bad rap these days. It causes belly fat, insomnia, anxiety, high blood sugar, and a host of other issues. It would seem as though it's a terrible substance that we should strive never to have. If more cortisol is bad then less cortisol should be good, right?
Ah, if only the body was that simple. The truth is that cortisol is a remarkably important hormone that doesn't only wreak havoc. It enables us to respond to stress, regulate blood sugar and even wake up in the morning.
But when cortisol is out of whack, that imbalance can be felt in many different body systems.
And mid-life, with all the other hormone changes we experience, is a very common time for cortisol to be dysregulated.
How midlife hormone changes affect cortisol…
For women (perimenopause and menopause):
As estrogen drops, cortisol levels tend to rise, especially in the later stages of perimenopause and especially at night (ugh).
Estrogen normally helps calm the body's stress response. With less estrogen, your body may react more strongly to stress.
This can contribute to:
Hot flashes/night sweats
Sleep issues
Changes in body composition/weight gain
Increase in cholesterol and triglycerides
Feeling on edge, irritable, anxious
For men (declining testosterone):
Stress hormones and testosterone affect each other.
Long-term stress and high cortisol can lower testosterone.
Low testosterone may make the body less able to handle stress.
This can show up as fatigue, low sex drive, loss of muscle, mood changes, and poor sleep.
Does hormone therapy fix cortisol?
Maybe! Estrogen therapy in women can calm the body's stress response, though not always or for everyone. It often takes away some of the stressors, though, so that indirectly helps.
Testosterone therapy in older men, hasn't been shown in studies to improve cortisol levels, but men often report an experience of less stress symptoms.
The annoying truth is that it's a complicated interaction and everyone responds a bit differently. The best way to make decisions about hormone therapy is through discussion of your symptoms, goals, health history and risks with your trusted provider.
So what else can you do?
Protect your sleep: Sleep is one of the biggest factors you can impact. Poor sleep raises cortisol, and high cortisol makes sleep worse. Keep a regular bedtime, a cool dark bedroom, and limit alcohol and afternoon caffeine.
Move your body: Regular aerobic exercise and strength training help to regulate cortisol levels and improve stress symptoms.
Eat well: Choose whole foods, healthy proteins and limit processed sugar.
Manage stress: Try walking, breathing exercises, mindfulness/meditation, or spending time with others (who you like).
Cortisol-regulating supplements: We are fortunate in naturopathic medicine to have herbs and other nutrients that help to modulate cortisol and support our stress hormone system. Talk to your ND (or come see me) for specific recommendations.
The bottom line
Midlife hormone changes can impact how your body handles stress. You are not imagining that you feel less adept at handling things right now. Healthy habits, especially good sleep, are the most reliable way to support healthy cortisol levels, and supplements or hormones might be part of the answer too.
Joint Pain - The Peri/Menopause Symptom No One Talks About
No sitting allowed...
I’m going to do something I don’t always do which is to discuss this issue by way of my own personal story…
I’m 48 years old. In my early 40s I developed a lot of joint pain. I was never a chronic pain sort of person. My neck might hurt from bad posture at work or my shoulder might hurt from climbing, but everything always got better and I had the confidence and comfort that comes from knowing that. (Something that people with chronic pain typically do not have.)
But somewhere along the way it started to change. I would go to my chiropractor for one issue and then I would need to pivot to a new issue before the original one was resolved. I noticed I was acquiring problems faster than I was healing. Shoulders, neck, and then my right and then left SI (sacroiliac) joints really started nagging at me. Over time the pain encompassed both of my hip joints. It was ok when I was moving, but I could not sit comfortably in any type of chair for any extended period of time. And I couldn’t lie comfortably on either side. I felt like the universe was being very unkind – Dr. Rebecca, you must not rest!
I saw 2 chiropractors, 3 physical therapists and a massage therapist. I did yoga. I got an x-ray. I drank more water and removed certain foods. I took herbs and homeopathics. I would get very brief periods of relief, and the pain would move around seemingly randomly, but it never truly improved. It was incredibly persistent for years. I accepted I would probably have daily pain forever.
Then I got pregnant. I reinvigorated my rehab efforts out of fear. Low back/pelvis/hip pain is so common in pregnancy – how was I going to handle it if things have got worse? What was I going to do once I couldn’t lie on my back anymore, if sleeping on my sides was so painful? I braced myself for a really tough pregnancy.
And when I was a few months pregnant, the pain got significantly…better??
Not just better, it fully resolved. (It was quite the gift because I really wanted to be able to sit down by the time. I was seven months pregnant!) This confirmed what I had been suspicious of after all those years – perimenopause with falling estrogen was the cause of my pain. Sure enough, a few months after I had the baby, once those pregnancy hormones calmed down, my hip pain came back.
We hear a lot about hot flashes, weight gain and sleep issues in perimenopause and menopause. But joint pain is also one of the most common symptoms women deal with. More than half of women in perimenopause or after menopause have aches or stiffness in their muscles or joints. It often starts during perimenopause. After menopause, the pain is usually worse.
These changes seem to come from menopause itself, not only from getting older. Estrogen helps protect the joints. Cartilage, bones, and the tissues around joints all respond to estrogen. When estrogen drops, joints can become stiffer and more sore. Losing estrogen may also increase inflammation in the body.
Muscle loss, weight gain, poor sleep, stress, and low mood can all make pain feel worse!
So what can be done? Do we all just have to be stiff and achy forever?
Sometimes all the things that did not work for me really can help. (I realize this story is not a resounding endorsement of the recommendations below but everyone is different and I absolutely see improvement in patients with some of this!)
- Staying active through walking, swimming, and strength training help keep your muscles strong and joints healthy.
- Keeping a healthy weight takes pressure off your knees and hips.
- Protecting your sleep and mood makes pain easier to manage.
- Turmeric, quercetin, fish oil and bromelain are amongst the supplements that I've seen help women with joint pain.
And then there's hormone therapy. It's not always a hole-in-one, and we can never fully turn back the clock, but for a lot of women replenishing estrogen often reduces the severity of pain. I see this in clinic all the time, but we need better clinical research on the topic.
Joint pain around menopause is common and real! There are many ways to manage it. Talk with your health care team about what you're experiencing.
Testosterone for Men - The 3 Biggest Questions
Women's hormone health is getting a lot of attention these days (finally and rightfully so!), but men experience hormonal changes as they age, too. And the big one? Testosterone.
Testosterone begins to decline gradually, in most men, starting in their 30s. For many, levels remain within the normal range. But even when levels aren't fully below reference range, some men just don't feel great.
So what do men need to know about testosterone treatment? Here are the three questions I think are most important.
1. Should we be screening men for low testosterone, and if so, when?
As a naturopathic doctor, I tend to be a bit more proactive than conventional providers when it comes to screening. Testosterone naturally declines with age, but there is a lot of individual variation. Some older men maintain optimal levels while other men experience a more significant decline earlier in life. I see plenty of men in their 30s and 40s with levels that are low or borderline low.
I generally like to check testosterone at least once in male patients starting around age 40, and earlier if there are symptoms or other reasons for concern.
One important distinction: testosterone levels need to be interpreted in the context of symptoms. A number that falls within the laboratory reference range doesn't necessarily tell us the whole story, and a single low result isn't enough to diagnose testosterone deficiency.
2. What are the symptoms of low testosterone?
This is where things can get tricky because many symptoms of low testosterone overlap with other common health concerns.
Some of the more common symptoms include:
Fatigue
Decreased libido or sexual function issues
Loss of muscle mass and increased body fat
Difficulty building or maintaining muscle
Changes in mood, motivation, or mental clarity
Poor sleep
Reduced exercise performance and recovery
Not every man with low testosterone will experience all of these symptoms, and having these symptoms doesn't automatically mean testosterone is the problem. Sleep apnea, thyroid disorders, insulin resistance, chronic stress, nutritional deficiencies, and other factors can contribute to similar complaints. (Though most of these can also contribute to low testosterone!)
3. Should all men with low testosterone be on TRT?
The answer to this one is definitely "no". Testosterone replacement therapy (TRT) can be incredibly helpful for the right person, but it isn't something you should jump into without considering the bigger picture.
One of the biggest concerns with TRT is that supplementing with testosterone suppresses the body's own testosterone production, and this effect is not always reversible. TRT commonly lowers sperm production and causes testicular atrophy.
For men who are done having children, have significant symptoms, and have consistently low testosterone, replacement may be a very worthwhile option - sometimes life changing. But there are other approaches worth considering when a man isn't at that point yet.
Sleep, strength training, adequate nutrition, maintaining a healthy body composition, and addressing underlying metabolic issues can all support healthy testosterone levels. There are also certain nutrients and herbs that may be helpful depending on the individual.
The goal isn't necessarily to put every aging man on testosterone. It's to help men maintain healthy hormone levels and feel their best, using the least aggressive approach that gets the job done.
The bottom line:
Testosterone is an important hormone for men's energy, muscle mass, sexual health, metabolism, and overall well-being. While some decline with age is normal, feeling tired, losing muscle, or experiencing a decreased sex drive shouldn't automatically be dismissed as just getting older.
I think we should be paying more attention to men's hormone health, screening when appropriate, and looking at more than just a single lab value when making treatment decisions.
Author: Rebecca Principe, ND